Background: A multi-provincial outbreak of Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis was linked to newly hatched chicks and poults from a single hatchery during the spring of 2015. In total, there were 61 human cases that were epidemiologically confirmed to be linked to the chicks and poults and the outbreak was deemed to have ended in the summer of 2015.
Methods: PulseNet Canada, in coordination with the affected provinces, used genome sequencing of human and agricultural Salmonella Enteritidis isolates to aid in the epidemiological investigation, while also using traditional typing methods such as phagetyping and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE).
Results: All human outbreak cases, except one, were Phage Type (PT) 13a. Single nucleotide variant analysis (SNV) was able to provide a level of resolution commensurate with the results of the epidemiological investigation. SNV analysis was also able to separate PT13a outbreak-related isolates from isolates not linked to chicks or poults, while clustering some non-PT13a agricultural strains with the outbreak cluster.
Conclusions: Based on conventional typing methods (phagetyping or PFGE), clinical and agricultural PT13a SE isolates would have been considered as part of a related cluster. In contrast, phagetyping would have led to the exclusion of several non- PT13a strains that clustered with the outbreak isolates using the genome sequence data. This study demonstrates the improved resolution of genome sequence analysis for coordinated surveillance and source attribution of both human and agricultural SE isolates.
Funding StatementThis work was supported by in-kind mandate-dedicated funding from the Public Health Agency of Canada, Public Health (BCCDC, Provincial Laboratory for Public Health in Alberta) and Agriculture (AAF, BC MAgri) Laboratories.
Salmonellosis is one of the most common enteric foodborne illnesses reported in Canada. The Public Health Agency of Canada estimated the annual incidence of Salmonella enterica related foodborne illness at approximately 269 cases per 100,000 population1. In Canada, Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis (SE) is the most common laboratory confirmed serotype found in cases of human salmonellosis2. Phagetypes (PT) 8, 13, and 13a make up the majority of domestically acquired human cases, while the same PTs are also predominant in chickens3. Not surprisingly, Salmonella places a major burden on health, economic and agricultural systems.
Recently, the United States has reported a number of multi-jurisdictional Salmonella (various serotypes) outbreaks linked to live poultry from mail-order hatcheries4,5,6,7 and backyard flocks6,7, including an epidemiological review of 53 outbreaks related to live poultry from 1990 through 20148. Starting in the spring of 2015, several Canadian provinces experienced outbreaks of SE that were traced back, epidemiologically, to the sale of recently hatched chicks and poults from a single hatchery. A total of 61 SE-related human illnesses were reported from the provinces of Alberta, British Columbia, Manitoba, the Northwest Territories and Saskatchewan, between January and June 2015. While Canada has several different surveillance systems for Salmonella that captures investigations from human, food, and environmental isolates, it has traditionally been difficult to link isolates due to the limited resolution provided by traditional methods such as pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) and phagetyping (PT). Historically, SE isolates from agricultural sources have rarely been included in surveillance activities, creating a major gap in data acquisition. As PulseNet Canada modernizes its surveillance system to use genome sequencing of enteric pathogens, this outbreak was an opportunity to use a high-resolution typing method, single nucleotide variant (SNV) analysis, of SE isolates from multi-provincial clinical and agricultural sources to corroborate the epidemiological investigation. Analysis of genome sequencing data has previously been demonstrated for surveillance and outbreaks of several Salmonella serovars in Canada9 , United States10, Australia11 and the UK12,13. The SNV analysis in this study was done in conjunction with federal epidemiologists to support the outbreak investigation. Much like the international effort published by Public Health England, and their tracking of SE in an egg distribution network, this example further demonstrates the utility of using genome sequencing for outbreak investigation and source attribution.
All clinical SE isolates were recovered at provincial public health laboratories from Alberta, British Columbia, Manitoba, New Brunswick, Newfoundland, Prince Edward Island, Quebec, and Saskatchewan. Agricultural isolates were provided by the British Columbia Ministry of Agriculture Animal Health Centre (BC MAgri) and Alberta Agriculture and Forestry (AAF). Salmonella was identified using standard biochemical assays, and serotyped following the Kauffmann-White scheme14,15. Phagetyping (PT) was performed at the Public Health Agency of Canada National Microbiology Laboratory (PHAC-NML) in Winnipeg and Guelph. PFGE was performed using PulseNet’s standard operating procedure16 on human and agricultural SE PT13a isolates received between January and June 2015 at provincial public health laboratories, AAF Agri-Food Laboratories, PHAC-NML, and PHAC-NML-Guelph. Non-PT13a isolates were included where one or both of the XbaI/BlnI PFGE patterns matched the dominant PT13a PFGE patterns (i.e., SENXAI.0006 and/or SENBNI.0007).
Genomic DNA was isolated from the SE isolates using the Qiagen DNeasy Blood & Tissue kit (Mississauga, Ontario) and sequencing libraries were generated using the Illumina Nextera XT library preparation kit (San Diego, California). The samples were sequenced by the Genomics Unit at the PHAC-NML using a 2 x 300 bp (600 cycle) Illumina MiSeq Reagent Kit v3 on an Illumina MiSeq. All sequences are available at NCBI under BioProject PRJNA343897.
Single Nucleotide Variant Calling
The Single Nucleotide Variant Phylogenomics (SNVPhyl) pipeline17, designed by the NML bioinformatics team, was used to call single nucleotide variants (SNV) using a SPAdes18 assembled (closed by Sanger sequencing) BC SE isolate 08-3405 (PT8; PFGE SENXAI.0003/SENBNI.003) as the reference genome. The phylogenetic tree was generated using plotTree.py19, a wrapper script for the ETE toolkit20.
Results and Discussion
PHAC-NML sequenced SE isolated from clinical cases that had occurred between January and June 2015 and that had PFGE-Xbal pattern SENXAI.0006. Agricultural SE isolates that coincided with the clinical investigation from hatchery samples and trace-out farms with PFGE profiles SENXAI.0006/SENBNI.0007 were forwarded to PHAC-NML for sequencing, regardless of phagetype. SE isolates from trace-back samples from backyard flock owners were sent directly to PHAC-NML for sequencing without PFGE characterization. PFGE using a second enzyme, BlnI, was completed on 492 of 574 isolates, and the majority exhibited the SENBNI.0007 pattern (477 of 492 isolates). Of the 574 SE isolates in the study, 527 were PT13a, with the remaining 47 isolates typed as PT8, PT13, PT19, PT22, PT23, ATEN-83 or atypical. Moreover, of the 47 non-PT13a SE isolates, 39 shared the same SENXAI.0006 PFGE pattern as 520 of the PT13a SE isolates, demonstrating the obfuscation of using PFGE or PT to rule in or rule out epidemiological linkages.
In total, 575 SE isolates were sequenced (574 plus the reference 08-3405) on the Illumina MiSeq. Of these sequenced SE isolates, 149 were clinical isolates (including 08-3405 reference) and 426 were agricultural isolates (AAF: 226; BC MAgri: 200). Sixty of the 149 sequenced clinical SE isolates had confirmed exposure to chicks or poults (Alberta: 35; British Columbia: 18; Manitoba: 1; and Saskatchewan: 6). Not all confirmed clinical cases from the epidemiological investigation were sequenced.
The distribution of clinical isolates is shown in Figure 1.
The sequenced isolates were clustered using the SNVPhyl pipeline, which identified 441 high quality SNVs (hqSNVs) for phylogenetic reconstruction (Figure 2).
The SE genomes from the epidemiologically confirmed cases (dark grey lines, Figure 2) clustered in one large clade called the outbreak clade (red branches, Figure 2). This outbreak clade contains 493 of the sequenced isolates, including clinical isolates from Alberta, British Columbia, Manitoba, and Saskatchewan, as well as SE isolates collected by the BC MAgri and AAF. There was a maximum of 8 hqSNV differences between the 493 isolates (range 0 – 8 SNVs). While the majority of SE isolates were PT13a, 42 isolates were non-PT13a (black square in Figure 2), suggesting that SE phagetype results may not be sufficiently discriminatory to exclude an isolate from epidemiological investigation. This is supported by technical challenges and limitations of Salmonella phagetyping21, compounded by biological changes that can lead to phagetype conversion22. During the clustering of all of the SE isolates, two additional clades outside of the outbreak clade emerged. The first clade (gold branches, Figure 2) consisted of 18 clinical SE isolates from British Columbia and Manitoba. The second clade (green branches, Figure 2) was made up of 15 BC SE isolates, 1 of which was collected from BC MAgri. These two clusters were not followed up epidemiologically. These omissions illustrate the ability of genomics-based methods to identify potential linkages of clinical isolates to other provinces or sectors, such as agriculture, and highlight the need for improved surveillance methods based on better isolate characterization.
Sixty-one human cases [Alberta (35), British Columbia (19), Manitoba (1), NWT (1), and Saskatchewan (5)], were linked to the outbreak by epidemiological investigation23; 58 of these isolates were sequenced in this study. All patients recalled contact with live chicks or poults23. The SNV-based analysis also clustered 12 clinical isolates with the outbreak clade that were either unconfirmed or were not included in the epidemiological investigation (Figure 2). This highlights the added value of performing real-time genome sequencing on a routine basis in reference laboratories, as SNV-based clustering of Salmonella genome sequences can better rule-out relationships more accurately than traditional methods (e.g., PFGE and PT). The ability to include and exclude isolates through SNV-based clustering can provide better targeted data for epidemiological investigations, increase the likelihood of finding a source and in a timelier fashion, and provide a more effective prevention strategy to reduce illness and economic loss.
Illnesses associated with the implicated hatchery exemplifies how salmonellosis causes a high economic burden of illness on the health-care system, and as well, on the agricultural industry and the economy as a whole. This burden will continue unless better discriminatory techniques are applied to clinical and agricultural SE isolates to promote better source tracking, and enable targeted mitigation actions and prevention of food-borne illness. Integrated surveillance to capture the full farm-to-fork spectrum of SE is critical in providing a scientific base for source attribution, informing policies and intervention/prevention strategies, and ultimately reducing financial burdens on the health care, food and agricultural systems.
Contact with live poultry was linked to over 500 cases of salmonellosis in the US in 2013 and 20144,5, and during the following two years, over 1,100 salmonellosis cases were linked to backyard flocks6,7. Routine genome sequencing of Salmonella by Public Health England (BioProject PRJNA248792) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s PulseNet USA (BioProject PRJNA230403)13, and the United States Food and Drug Administration’s GenomeTrakr (BioProject PRJNA183844)24 sets a new standard with a model for genomic data sharing that also provides a wealth of information for international surveillance. Given the time frame of the Canadian outbreak in 2015, comparisons of the deposited SE sequences in GenomeTrakr during these concurrent outbreaks linked to live poultry6 could have provided an opportunity to compare our SE outbreak isolates with those collected south of the border. Successful international source-attribution was exemplified by Public Health England, linking SE cases internationally to eggs – actions all driven by analysis of genome sequence data12. Given this framework, it is clear that genome sequencing can provide source attribution of clinical isolates as the current gold standard for rapid response and preventive public health activities. It is also the new gold standard for source attribution and pan-system collaborations. We believe that genome sequencing-based surveillance standardized at the national and international level, will provide the foundation to begin to fill the knowledge gap between SE illness in the human population and source attribution in the agriculture, and food sectors.
Detection of foodborne illness by PulseNet USA was estimated to prevent approximately 270,000 cases of foodborne illness each year, saving $500 million in costs to the US economy25. As the PulseNet USA program is reported to cost $7.3 million per year, the cost of surveillance programs far outweighs the costs of uncontrolled outbreaks of foodborne illness. Although the estimated burden of foodborne illness to the Canadian economy is lower than that of the United States, salmonellosis still causes frequent outbreaks of foodborne illness each year in Canada and is associated with a high economic toll. For every reported case, there are an estimated 26 unreported cases in Canada1. Although these cases may not be the largest strain on health-care, they are still an unnecessary burden on a system that is cost-constrained and can result in loss of productivity and other economic costs associated with absence from work. Development of standardized methods for routine use of genome sequencing at the national and international levels, of other enteric pathogens should further improve on these SE successes. This approach is now being adopted by PulseNet USA, the Food and Drug Administration24, Public Health England13,26, and PulseNet Canada, among others worldwide.
This was the first outbreak in Canada to provide direct evidence of how genome sequencing can perform source attribution and provide improved data for targeted outbreak investigations salmonellosis. This multi-discipline, multi-jurisdictional, and collaborative investigation also highlighted the importance of timely integrated surveillance based on the farm-to-fork continuum and a One Health concept. While this outbreak investigation was completed without genome sequence analysis, SNV-based clustering was effective for source-tracking of SE during an outbreak associated with exposure to live chicks and poults, while also identifying potentially related clinical isolates that were not epidemiologically investigated. Additionally, other clusters were identified that contained either multi-provincial SE isolates, or clinical isolates with agricultural isolates, illustrating the ability of genome sequencing to provide more information than PT or PFGE for epidemiological investigation. Genome sequencing in provincial public health laboratories on a routine basis has the potential for significant savings to the health care system, agricultural/food industries, and to the Canadian economy. Given the challenges and limitations of conventional typing methods such as PFGE and phagetyping, and the worldwide success and resolution of genome sequence analysis, PulseNet Canada will be ceasing phagetyping and PFGE and is moving towards genome sequencing as the gold standard for surveillance, outbreak investigations, and source attribution.
Robin King, Alberta Agriculture and Forestry, Edmonton, Alberta. email@example.com
The authors have no competing interests to declare.
All sequence data is available at NCBI under BioProject PRJNA343897. All corresponding data (e.g., PT, PFGE) can be found in the Supplementary Table available under doi:10.6084/m9.figshare.5007773.v1 on figshare.
AcknowledgementsWe would like to thank the PulseNet Canada Steering Committee for their comments and suggestions during the investigation and manuscript preparation. We are also grateful to all of the technical staff involved in this investigation, including the Bacteriology and Bacterial Typing Unit (Provincial Laboratory for Public Health in Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta), Agri-Food Laboratories (Alberta Agriculture and Forestry, Edmonton, Alberta), Animal Health Centre (BC Ministry of Agriculture, Abbotsford, British Columbia), Public Health Advanced Bacteriology & Mycology Program (BCCDC Public Health Laboratories, Vancouver, British Columbia), Laboratory for Foodborne Zoonoses (Public Health Agency of Canada, Guelph, Ontario), and the National Microbiology Laboratory Genomics Core (Public Health Agency of Canada, Winnipeg, Manitoba). We would also like to acknowledge Dr. Judith Isaac-Renton for her critical feedback and comments on the manuscript, and Philip Mabon for his technical support. We would also like to thank all of the local, provincial, and federal epidemiologists for their work during this outbreak.
- Thomas MK, Murray R, Flockhart L, Pintar K, Pollari F, Fazil A, Nesbitt A, Marshall B. Estimates of the burden of foodborne illness in Canada for 30 specified pathogens and unspecified agents, circa 2006. Foodborne Pathog Dis. 2013 Jul;10(7):639-48. PubMed PMID:23659355.
- Government of Canada. National Enteric Surveillance Program (NESP) Annual Summary 2013. Public Health Agency of Canada, Guelph; 2015
- Nesbitt A, Ravel A, Murray R, McCormick R, Savelli C, Finley R, Parmley J, Agunos A, Majowicz SE, Gilmour M. Integrated surveillance and potential sources of Salmonella enteritidis in human cases in Canada from 2003 to 2009. Epidemiol Infect. 2012 Oct;140(10):1757-72. PubMed PMID:22166269.
- Basler C, Forshey TM, Machesky K, Erdman MC, Gomez TM, Nguyen TA, Behravesh CB. Multistate outbreak of human Salmonella infections linked to live poultry from a mail-order hatchery in Ohio--March-September 2013. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2014 Mar 14;63(10):222. PubMed PMID:24622287.
- Basler C, Forshey TM, Machesky K, Erdman CM, Gomez TM, Brinson DL, Nguyen TA, Behravesh CB, Bosch S. Notes from the field: multistate outbreak of human salmonella infections linked to live poultry from a mail-order hatchery in Ohio--February-October 2014. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2015 Mar 13;64(9):258. PubMed PMID:25763879.
- Four Multistate Outbreaks of Human Salmonella Infections Linked to Live Poultry in Backyard Flocks (Final Update) | Salmonella Infections Linked to Live Poultry | July 2015 | Salmonella | CDC. [cited 12 Sep 2016]
- Seven Multistate Outbreaks of Human Salmonella Infections Linked to Live Poultry in Backyard Flocks | June 2016 | Salmonella | CDC. [cited 12 Sep 2016]
- Basler C, Nguyen TA, Anderson TC, Hancock T, Behravesh CB. Outbreaks of Human Salmonella Infections Associated with Live Poultry, United States, 1990-2014. Emerg Infect Dis. 2016 Oct;22(10):1705-11. PubMed PMID:27649489.
- Bekal S, Berry C, Reimer AR, Van Domselaar G, Beaudry G, Fournier E, Doualla-Bell F, Levac E, Gaulin C, Ramsay D, Huot C, Walker M, Sieffert C, Tremblay C. Usefulness of High-Quality Core Genome Single-Nucleotide Variant Analysis for Subtyping the Highly Clonal and the Most Prevalent Salmonella enterica Serovar Heidelberg Clone in the Context of Outbreak Investigations. J Clin Microbiol. 2016 Feb;54(2):289-95. PubMed PMID:26582830.
- Taylor AJ, Lappi V, Wolfgang WJ, Lapierre P, Palumbo MJ, Medus C, Boxrud D. Characterization of Foodborne Outbreaks of Salmonella enterica Serovar Enteritidis with Whole-Genome Sequencing Single Nucleotide Polymorphism-Based Analysis for Surveillance and Outbreak Detection. J Clin Microbiol. 2015 Oct;53(10):3334-40. PubMed PMID:26269623.
- Octavia S, Wang Q, Tanaka MM, Kaur S, Sintchenko V, Lan R. Delineating community outbreaks of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium by use of whole-genome sequencing: insights into genomic variability within an outbreak. J Clin Microbiol. 2015 Apr;53(4):1063-71. PubMed PMID:25609719.
- Dallman T, Inns T, Jombart T, Ashton P, Loman N, Chatt C, Messelhaeusser U, Rabsch W, Simon S, Nikisins S, Bernard H, le Hello S, Jourdan da-Silva N, Kornschober C, Mossong J, Hawkey P, de Pinna E, Grant K, Cleary P. Phylogenetic structure of European Salmonella Enteritidis outbreak correlates with national and international egg distribution network. Microb Genom. 2016 Aug;2(8):e000070. PubMed PMID:28348865.
- Ashton PM, Peters T, Ameh L, McAleer R, Petrie S, Nair S, Muscat I, de Pinna E, Dallman T. Whole Genome Sequencing for the Retrospective Investigation of an Outbreak of Salmonella Typhimurium DT 8. PLoS Curr. 2015 Feb 10;7. PubMed PMID:25713745.
- Grimont PAD, Weill F-X. Antigenic formulae of the Salmonella serovars (9th edition). WHO Collaborating Centre for Reference and Research on Salmonella, Institut Pasteur, Paris, France; 2007.
- Issenhuth-Jeanjean S, Roggentin P, Mikoleit M, Guibourdenche M, de Pinna E, Nair S, Fields PI, Weill FX. Supplement 2008-2010 (no. 48) to the White-Kauffmann-Le Minor scheme. Res Microbiol. 2014 Sep;165(7):526-30. PubMed PMID:25049166.
- PulseNet. Standard Operating Procedure for PulseNet PFGE of Escherichia coli O157:H7, Escherichia coli non-O157 (STEC), Salmonella serotypes, Shigella sonnei and Shigella flexneri. 2013.
- Petkau A, Mabon P, Sieffert C, Knox N, Cabral J, Iskander M, Iskander M, Weedmark K, Zaheer R, Katz L, Nadon C, Reimer A, Taboada E, Beiko R, Hsiao W, Brinkman F, Graham M, Van Domselaar G. SNVPhyl: A Single Nucleotide Variant Phylogenomics pipeline for microbial genomic epidemiology. M Gen 3(6) 2017; doi:10.1099/mgen.0.000116
- Bankevich A, Nurk S, Antipov D, Gurevich AA, Dvorkin M, Kulikov AS, Lesin VM, Nikolenko SI, Pham S, Prjibelski AD, Pyshkin AV, Sirotkin AV, Vyahhi N, Tesler G, Alekseyev MA, Pevzner PA. SPAdes: a new genome assembly algorithm and its applications to single-cell sequencing. J Comput Biol. 2012 May;19(5):455-77. PubMed PMID:22506599.
- GitHub - katholt/plotTree
- Huerta-Cepas J, Serra F, Bork P. ETE 3: Reconstruction, Analysis, and Visualization of Phylogenomic Data. Mol Biol Evol. 2016 Jun;33(6):1635-8. PubMed PMID:26921390.
- Baggesen DL, Sørensen G, Nielsen EM, Wegener HC. Phage typing of Salmonella Typhimurium - is it still a useful tool for surveillance and outbreak investigation? Euro Surveill. 2010 Jan 28;15(4):19471. PubMed PMID:20122382.
- Brown DJ, Baggesen DL, Platt DJ, Olsen JE. Phage type conversion in Salmonella enterica serotype Enteritidis caused by the introduction of a resistance plasmid of incompatibility group X (IncX). Epidemiol Infect. 1999 Feb;122(1):19-22. PubMed PMID:10098781.
- Government of Canada PHA of C. Public Health Notice - Outbreak of Salmonella infections related to contact with live baby poultry - Public Health Agency of Canada. 25 May 2015 [cited 10 Feb 2017].
- Allard MW, Strain E, Melka D, Bunning K, Musser SM, Brown EW, Timme R. Practical Value of Food Pathogen Traceability through Building a Whole-Genome Sequencing Network and Database. J Clin Microbiol. 2016 Aug;54(8):1975-83. PubMed PMID:27008877.
- 20 Years of PulseNet. [cited 12 Sep 2016]
- Dallman TJ, Byrne L, Ashton PM, Cowley LA, Perry NT, Adak G, Petrovska L, Ellis RJ, Elson R, Underwood A, Green J, Hanage WP, Jenkins C, Grant K, Wain J. Whole-genome sequencing for national surveillance of Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli O157. Clin Infect Dis. 2015 Aug 1;61(3):305-12. PubMed PMID:25888672.