plos PLoS Currents: Disasters 2157-3999 Public Library of Science San Francisco, USA 10.1371/currents.dis.a0351bdc63f477245858caa7638e8525 Research Article Landscape of WASH-relevant Training for Humanitarian Emergencies Dorea Caetano 11 5 2015 ecurrents.dis.a0351bdc63f477245858caa7638e8525 2018 Dorea, et al This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Background: Both employed humanitarian personnel as well as those seeking to start a career as an aid worker are often provided with or seek training on the theme of humanitarian water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH). The objective of this study was to conduct a landscaping exercise of the available WASH-relevant training for humanitarian emergencies.

Methods: An open internet search was performed with specific terms related to humanitarian WASH. Retained search results included those training opportunities (including past ones) that were themed around or with a mentioned relevance to humanitarian WASH.

Results and Discussion: A total of 42 training courses relevant to humanitarian emergency WASH were retained. In addition to the more generic/introductory trainings, some provided thematic variations such as coordination of WASH responses, project management, risk reduction, information, education and communication (IEC), and complex emergencies. Timely topics such as urban WASH, Ebola, and WASH innovations were also observed indicating the responsiveness of the training providers to the changing needs of humanitarian WASH response programmes. This survey also revealed a large variety in terms of target audience, duration, fees, location, and language of courses. There was no centralised listing of courses available on the Internet. Limitations of this exercise were also discussed.

Caetano Dorea is supported by a CNPq (Brazilian National Council for Scientific and Technological Development) Research Fellowship (Grant 400576/2013-9). CD regularly delivers WASH-related trainings to NGOs as a private consultant (none included in this study). He is also a Visiting Research Fellow at RedR-India (Pune, India), but is not involved in RedR-India's training activities. The CNPq and RedR-India had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. The author has declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction

Humanitarian emergencies, whether natural or manmade, often require relief interventions in water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) to prevent the spread of diarrhoeal diseases. Such illnesses can be one of the major contributors to the overall morbidity and mortality rates following a disaster1,2. Typically, when the (re-)establishment of adequate WASH infrastructures is beyond the capacity of local authorities, aid from external relief agencies is warranted. In addition to dedicated equipment and other relief items, such organisations use specialised relief personnel to coordinate and deliver WASH interventions during recovery efforts. It is often the case that such personnel are either expatriate relief workers or locally-hired staff. In both cases, humanitarian WASH training is many times offered or required. The anecdotally romantic view that a relevant expertise and lots of goodwill were sufficient to secure a posting as an aid worker no longer holds true. Qualified personnel (e.g. engineers and health professionals) interested in becoming aid workers now seek such training to further specialise their skills and learn more about humanitarian work.

In 2007 Oxfam International3 reported that over the previous two decades the total number of natural disasters has increased four-fold and that the number of affected people from such events has risen on average from 174 million to 250 million a year. Moreover, since the end of the Cold War in 1991, an increase in the number of violent manmade conflicts has also been noticed4 affecting a growing number of civilian populations. Evidence of this changing landscape may also be found in the overall increasing trend humanitarian funding and response personnel with an estimated annual growth rate of 6 percent5, as pointed out by Walker et al.6. The increase in such statistics will likely reflect an increase of humanitarian support WASH personnel, given the importance (and near ubiquity) of WASH interventions during such catastrophic events. Adequate training programmes are thus warranted to ensure professional development, accountability to beneficiaries, and building trust with donors.

Walker and Russ7 conducted a scoping study on the professionalisation of the humanitarian sector and presented a database of mostly non-specific humanitarian training that was available. More recently, Jacquet et al.8 presented a mainly literature-based survey (albeit non-systematically), but also with a broad “humanitarian response” remit and did not identify WASH-specific training. Furthermore, it concentrated on more traditional (“in-class”) type training, as distance learning options (i.e. online or paper-based) were not included in their assessment. The objective of this study was to conduct a landscaping exercise of the available WASH-relevant training for humanitarian emergencies.

Methods

An open internet search was performed in English with Google web search engine (www.google.ca) using a combination of the terms “water,” “sanitation,” “hygiene,” “WASH,” “watsan,” “humanitarian,” “emergencies,” “disasters,” “relief,” “course,” and “training” with no search operators. Due to the large number of results obtained through open internet searches (sometimes over 40,000,000), only the first 50 results for each search were evaluated for inclusion in the study. In addition to the primary search results, secondary references were also followed up. These searches were conducted between December 2014 and February 2015. Websites were typically visited only once for information retrieval. Retained search results included those training opportunities (including past ones) that were themed around water, sanitation and/or hygiene dedicated to or with mentioned relevance to humanitarian relief. Generic (i.e. non-specific to emergencies) WASH trainings were not included in this exercise. When possible the name, organiser, location, delivery mode (e.g. presential or online), duration, fees (converted to USD), and language (assumed to be the same of the information source when not explicit) were noted.

Results

A total of 42 training courses relevant to humanitarian emergency WASH were retained for this exercise. Whereas this search was not exhaustive with regards to the existing plethora of (generic) WASH training courses, it identified emergency WASH-related opportunities that are largely advertised to the general public. Although some courses were also part of a larger academic postgraduate study programme. Many organisations can offer “in-house” trainings (sometimes contracted out to third parties) that are not advertised and are restricted to their employees. Conferences and workshops with relevance to humanitarian emergency WASH also can provide valuable learning opportunities, which were not covered by this study. The open internet search also revealed “general” WASH-relevant courses that were not specific to humanitarian emergencies. Whilst there can be a strong overlap of content that is applicable to humanitarian contexts, such results were not within the scope of the performed search. The retained search results were categorised according to their delivery mode. For presential courses, the reported durations varied from 1 day to 10 months. Online trainings were anywhere between 2 hours of duration to up to 150 contact hours. Their characteristics were summarised in Tables 1 and 2.

NS = not stated.

Name Organiser Location Duration Fee (USD) Language
Introduction to Hygiene Promotion in Emergencies RedR-UK London, UK 1 155 to 379 English
Sustainable Sanitation in Emergencies and Reconstruction Situations German Toilet Organization NS 2 NS German
Hygiene Promotion and Behaviour Change German Toilet Organization Berlin, Germany 2 NS German
Emergency Water, Sanitation and Hygiene (WASH) Engineering: Hands-on Weekend Engineers Without Borders - UK Wakefield, UK 3 147 English
Public Health Promotion in Emergencies RedR-India NS 3 NS Hindi
Hygiene Promotion in Emergencies RedR-India Guwahati, India 4 343 to 526 English
WASH Essentials in Emergencies RedR-UK Nairobi, Kenya 5 246 English
Hygiene Promotion Training for Trainers for Emergency Contexts IDEAL Public Health and Development Consultancy Nairobi, Kenya 5 600 English
Master Essential Rural and Periurban WASH Techniques Bioforce Bamako, Mali 5 683 French
Coordinating Hygiene Promotion & Favour Community Participation Bioforce Bamako, Mali 5 683 French
Managing Emergency Sanitation & Sustainable Sanitation Bioforce Bamako, Mali 5 683 French
Technical Training in Water & Sanitation Bushproof Antananarivo, Madagascar 5 1708 English
Urban WASH in Emergencies RedR-UK London, UK 5 860 to 2080 English
WASH in Emergencies RedR-UK Khartoum, Sudan 5 860 to 2080 English
Advanced Technologies for Water and Sanitation Cranfield University Cranfield, UK 5 1966 to 2151 English
Emergency Water Supply and Environmental Sanitation Cranfield University Cranfield, UK 5 1966 to 5151 English
Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene (WASH) In Emergencies Training Department of Health (Gov. of the Rep. of the Philippines) NS 5 NS English
WASH in Emergency Training Roberto Saltori (Private Consultant) Sando, Sweden 5 NS English
WatSan in Emergency Training Austrian Red Cross Laubegg, Austria 7 Free English
Environmental Health in Emergencies RedR-India Pune, India 7 343 to 565 English
Engineering in Emergencies RedR-India Kathmandu, Nepal 7 424 to 750 English
NTS 004 WASH in emergencies: Risk Reduction Netwas International Nairobi, Kenya 7 949 to 1680 English
Water, Sanitation & Hygiene in Emergencies RedR-Australia Dookie, Australia 7 1234 to 1912 English
Water and Sanitation Engineering from Emergency Towards Development University of Neuchâtel & the International Committee of the Red Cross Neuchâtel, Switzerland 7 2151 English
Coordinating Emergency WASH Responses: Lessons Learnt from Western and Central Africa Bioforce Bamako, Mali 10 1708 French
Health Emergencies in Large Populations (HELP) Johns Hopkins University & International Committee of the Red Cross Baltimore, USA 10 1899 to 4930 English
Specialisation in Ebola Management for Log/WASH Professionals Bioforce Lyon, France 13 569 English
Learn the Specific Competencies of WASH Professionals Bioforce Lyon, France & Bamako, Mali 20 to 27 2074 French
Water Supply and Sanitation in Emergencies University of Copenhagen Copenhagen, Denmark 4 weeks 2829 to 3824 English
Advanced Master’s Degree in Humanitarian WASH International Institute for Water and Environmental Engineering Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso 10 months 6688 to 7895 English
Water, Sanitation and Hygiene RedR-Malaysia NS NS NS English
Water and Ecological Sanitation in Crisis Contexts Groupe u.r.d. NS NS NS French

NS = not stated. * indicates duration expressed as the reported "contact hours" (i.e. including self study hours).

Name Organiser Duration Fee (USD) Language
Development, Disasters and Sanitation Loughborough University 2 15 English
Information, Education and Communication (IEC) in WASH emergencies Oxfam 6 Free English
Technical Project Management (TPM) in WASH Emergencies Oxfam 14 Free English
Emergency Sanitation (CVP282) Loughborough University 150* 1693 English
Emergency Water Supply (CVP281) Loughborough University 150* 1693 English
Emergency Water Supply and Sanitation: A WELL Course Loughborough University NS Free English
Water Sanitation Needs in Complex Humanitarian Emergencies Johns Hopkins University NS Free English
Refugee Health Care Johns Hopkins University & International Committee of the Red Cross NS Free English
Public Health e-learning UNCHR NS Free English
Health in Humanitarian Crises Advanced Training Program on Humanitarian Action (ATHA) NS Free English

Discussion

The content of most of the available trainings was centered on notions of emergency water supply (e.g. water quality, treatment, distribution, etc.), sanitation (e.g. latrine types, faecal sludge management, etc.), and hygiene (e.g. handwashing, hygiene promotion methods and approaches, behaviour change, etc.), as well as overarching themes (e.g. SPHERE Standards, diarrhoeal disease transmission, etc.). However, some courses provided thematic variations such as coordination of WASH responses, project management, risk reduction, information, education and communication (IEC), and complex emergencies. Timely topics such as urban WASH, Ebola, menstrual hygiene management, and WASH innovations were also observed indicating the responsiveness of the training providers to the changing needs of humanitarian WASH response programmes. There did not seem to be any obvious topic omission. However, there could be specialised themes that were not covered in the training opportunities that were largely aimed at a rather generic humanitarian audience.

Fees for the training courses also varied substantially. Whereas some online ones were offered free of charge, others cost between 15 and 7895 USD. Variation between courses are thought to be related to the duration and venue of the trainings. Price variations were also observed within courses according to several factors such as inclusion of accommodation and meals, student status, group registration, professional status (e.g. NGO, local government, etc.), academic credit or non-credit bearing, residency status, medical insurance, etc.

This scoping exercise revealed mainly training opportunities in English, as it was biased by the Language in which the open internet search that was performed. It is possible that a search in other languages would reveal an even greater number and variety. Although all of the information retrieved for this exercise was in English, some course information stated content delivery in languages other than English (e.g. French, German, and Hindi). Moreover, given that some organisations offered bespoke on demand courses, it is likely that these can be offered in other languages (or dialects).

Although the training courses were largely advertised to the general public, their intended audience varied. While the target clientele was not consistently indicated, the training opportunities were aimed at humanitarian WASH professionals, engineers, technicians, public health/medical professionals, logisticians, project managers, programme coordinators, and graduate students. Previous experience was generally not a requirement. Some courses required a minimum number of registrations in order to take place.

In some instances, distribution certificates of completion were explicitly mentioned. Nonetheless, this is thought to be the norm with such type of trainings. No trainings were part of a recognised humanitarian WASH certification, as in general humanitarian occupational standards do not exist7. In this study the terms “certificates” and “certification” are used as defined elsewhere7. The professionalisation of the humanitarian sector is currently being discussed6. Relevant professional qualifications for WASH professionals are varied (e.g. engineers, social sciences, environmental or public health related disciplines), thus the professionalisation of humanitarian WASH workers may be a challenge. Moreover, many of such professionals are frequently certified through other professional organisations usually at a national level. On the other hand, minimum standards in humanitarian WASH interventions do exist9 and these are largely reflected on the delivered course content that was available. The information on course curricula that was analysed was limited to that available on searched websites. Therefore, it was not possible to identify and distil common points with regards to core competencies being developed and how they are being delivered. However, given the broad spectrum of relief activities that are included under the WASH acronym, it may be challenging to find a consensus with regards to core competencies in this theme.

This landscaping exercise revealed a large variety (in many aspects) of courses themed around humanitarian emergency WASH. There was no centralised listing of courses available on the Internet for those seeking training on the subject. Popular humanitarian-focused information portals such as ReliefWeb (www.reliefweb.int) that already host training listings in addition to other information (e.g. situation updates, country reports, job postings, etc.) could be potential candidates for a centralised repository. To this end, this survey can also be useful to those seeking WASH training to either gain awareness on the topic or to refresh their knowledge, as well as a starting point for those seeking to initiate a career in this field.

Appendix 1

Websites visited during this study for training course information retrieval: Download PDF

References Connolly MA, Gayer M, Ryan MJ, Salama P, Spiegel P, Heymann DL (2004) Communicable diseases in complex emergencies: impact and challenges. Lancet, 364(9449): 1974-83. Waring SC, Brown BJ (2005) The threat of communicable diseases following natural disasters: a public health response. Disaster Manag Response, 3(2): 41-7. 15829908 Oxfam International (2007) From weather alert to climate alarm. Oxfam Briefing Paper 108. Toole MJ (1997) Complex Emergencies: Refugee and other populations. In: EK Noji (ed.) The public health consequences of disasters. Oxford University Press: 419-42. Stoddard A, Harmer A, DiDomenico V (2009) Providing aid in insecure environments: 2009 update—trends in violence against aid workers and the operational response. Overseas Development Institute, HPG Policy Brief No. 34. Walker P, Hein K, Russ C, Bertleff G, Caspersz D (2010) A blueprint for professionalizing humanitarian assistance. Health Aff, 29(12): 2223-30. 21134923 Walker P, Russ C (2010) Professionalising the Humanitarian Sector: A scoping study. Enhanced Learning and Research for Humanitarian Assistance, Report. Jacquet GA, Obi CC, Chang MP, Bayram JD (2014) Availability and diversity of training programs for responders to international disasters and complex humanitarian emergencies. PLOS Curr. Disasters. 2014 Jun 23. Edition 1. doi: 10.1371/currents.dis.626ae97e629eccd4756f20de04a20823. 24987573 The Sphere Project (2011) The Sphere Handbook 2011: Humanitarian Charter and Minimum Standards in Humanitarian Response, 3rd ed.; Practical Action Publishing: Bourton on Dunsmore, U.K.